Free 15-minute fleet cost check. Call (855) 207-9352 or book a time online. Now offering vehicles too: ask about availability.

Fleet guide

Outsourcing vs. hiring a fleet manager.

At some point, running the vehicles becomes a job of its own. Here is an honest look at the two ways to cover it: hiring someone in-house, or handing it to an outsourced fleet management team.

The work that needs covering

Whichever route you choose, the job is the same. Someone has to schedule preventive maintenance, find and manage repair shops, review estimates, arrange replacement vehicles when one is down, track registrations and inspections, handle accidents and insurance claims, manage fuel cards, decide when to buy, lease, or replace vehicles, and report on what it all costs. In many small service businesses, that work is split between the owner, an office manager, and whoever has a free minute, which usually means it is done reactively.

Option 1: hire an in-house fleet manager

What you get. A person on your payroll who knows your vehicles, your crews, and your shops, and who can walk the yard and look at a truck. For larger fleets, an in-house manager can be the right call, especially if the job also includes things like yard management, parts inventory, or in-house mechanics.

What to weigh.

  • Total cost. Beyond salary, include payroll taxes, benefits, recruiting, training, software, and the time it takes a new hire to get up to speed. Use local salary data for your area to estimate the real number.
  • Coverage. One person takes vacations, gets sick, and goes home at night. Breakdowns and accidents do not keep office hours.
  • Fit. For a fleet of a dozen vans, fleet management may not be a full-time job, so the role often absorbs other duties and the fleet work slips again.
  • Risk. If that person leaves, the knowledge leaves with them.

Option 2: outsource fleet management

What you get. A team that does this work every day, with established processes for maintenance scheduling, vendor management, estimate review, renewals, and claims. You keep ownership of your vehicles and the major decisions; the team does the coordination and reports back.

What to weigh.

  • Cost. Usually a predictable monthly fee that scales with fleet size, rather than a salary. Third-party costs such as repairs and fuel are separate either way.
  • Coverage. A team can cover nights, weekends, and holidays in a way one employee cannot.
  • Distance. An outsourced team is not standing in your yard. Good communication and clear approval rules for repairs matter.
  • Control. Make sure you can see the records, set spending limits, and keep your preferred shops.

A quick comparison

In-house fleet managerOutsourced fleet management
Cost structureSalary, taxes, benefits, recruitingMonthly fee, often per vehicle
Hours coveredOne person's scheduleTeam coverage, often 24/7
Best fitLarger fleets, on-site needsSmall and growing service fleets
On-site presenceYesRemote, coordinates local shops
ContinuityDepends on one personProcess and records stay with the account
Scales with fleetStep changes when you hire againAdjusts by vehicle count

Questions to ask yourself

  1. How many hours a week do you and your staff spend on vehicle work today?
  2. What happens when a vehicle breaks down after hours?
  3. Do you know your per-vehicle cost for fuel, maintenance, and repairs?
  4. Is the fleet growing, and is anyone planning purchases and replacements?
  5. Would a full-time hire have enough fleet work to fill the role?

If the answers point to a part-time job that keeps getting pushed aside, outsourcing is usually worth a look. If you run a large fleet with on-site mechanics and a yard to manage, an in-house manager may make more sense, and some businesses combine both.

What outsourcing looks like with Fleet Command

Fleet Command Group is an outsourced fleet management team for service businesses, including HVAC, plumbing, electrical, landscaping, and roofing companies. We are not a long-haul trucking service. Our desk operates 24/7 with a one-hour emergency first-response target.

Pricing is published on the pricing page: every plan is a base monthly fee plus a per-vehicle fee, with no vehicles included in the base. Essentials is $250 a month plus $55 per vehicle (up to 25 vehicles), Operations Desk is $300 plus $65 per vehicle (up to 50), and Complete is $400 plus $80 per vehicle (up to 75). No onboarding fee. Third-party costs such as repairs, fuel, fees, and telematics are billed separately, so you always see what the shop or the pump actually charged.

At 15 vehicles, that is $1,075, $1,275, or $1,600 a month depending on the plan. Compare that against your own estimate of an in-house hire, and against the hours you spend on fleet work today.

Every engagement starts with a free fleet cost review. You tell us about your vehicles, leases, and current shops; we look at recent maintenance, repair, and fuel spend, upcoming renewals, and where downtime is costing you jobs, and we come back with a written plan. There is no obligation, and we do not promise specific savings, because those depend on how your fleet is run today. You can also call us at (855) 207-9352.

Find out where your fleet money is going.

Tell us about your vehicles. We will show you where money and time are leaking and what we would do about it. Free, with no obligation.

Call (855) 207-9352 Book free cost check